Dupe Score 91
Brow
Benefit vs Maybelline
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil, Deep Brown, 1…
95% matchSave 80%
Confirmed dupe
Revlondupe forBenefit
ColorStay Brow Fantasy Pencil and Gel, 003 Medium Brown·replaces .002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown
Save ~71%: Revlon ColorStay Brow Fantasy Pencil and Gel, 003 Medium Brown is our top budget pick vs Benefit .002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown (92% category/use-case overlap).
What you're replacing
Benefit .002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown
$19.95
Buy this instead
Revlon ColorStay Brow Fantasy Pencil and Gel, 003 Medium Brown
$5.76
Save $14 (71% less)
Why this dupe works
If you want the Benefit vibe without the splurge, start with Revlon ColorStay Brow Fantasy Pencil and Gel, 003 Medium Brown. Shoppers report similar results for everyday brow wear; swap only if you need the exact luxury shade, finish, or brand experience.
Before you switch
Dupes match category and use case — not always an identical shade or formula. Read the full comparison for shade and formula trade-offs.
Price drop alert
Notify me if this dupe gets cheaper
We watch Revlon ColorStay Brow Fantasy Pencil and Gel, 003 Medium Brown (currently $5.76) and email you when the price drops.
Free weekly emails
New Benefit dupes by email
We email when we add fresh matchups for this brand — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Keep exploring
Similar dupes you might like
Dupe Score 89
Brow
Benefit vs NYX
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Precision Eyebrow Pencil, Ash Brown
92% matchSave 84%
Dupe Score 87
Brow
Benefit vs Maybelline
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · Express Brow Ultra Slim Eyebrow Makeup, Brow Pencil…
91% matchSave 81%
Dupe Score 88
Brow
Benefit vs NYX
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Zero to Brow, Longwear Eyebrow…
91% matchSave 84%
Dupe Score 88
Brow
Benefit vs wet n wild
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · Ultimate Brow Micro Eyebrow Retractable Pencil, Soft…
91% matchSave 84%
Dupe Score 88
Brow
Benefit vs NYX
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP The Brow Glue, Extreme Hold…
91% matchSave 84%