Closest dupe
Dupe Score 93
L.A
. Girl Fanatic Eyeshadow Palette, The Nudist GES418
$7.41·Save 84%·Excellent dupe
✦ EyeshadowPremium pick
FAIRYTALE
Eyeshadow Palette
$44.99
List price · Amazon USD
- Dupes mapped
- 32
- Top save
- 85%
- Best score
- Dupe Score 93
Closest dupe
L.A
. Girl Fanatic Eyeshadow Palette, The Nudist GES418
$7.41
DupeScore 93 — save 84% vs FAIRYTALE. Same eyeshadow category; compare formula and finish before you swap.
Ranked alternatives
All dupes for FAIRYTALE Eyeshadow Palette
Every alternative is scored with our DupeScore — category overlap, savings, and match confidence. Order is computed, not sponsored.
Dupe Score 93
Mineral
Fusion Eyeshadow Palette (Glamping)
$9.09·Save 80%·Excellent dupe
Dupe Score 93
Bh Cosmetics
Baked Eyeshadow Palette, Supernova
$8.99·Save 80%·Excellent dupe
Dupe Score 92
Kiko
Milano Bright Quartet Eyeshadow Palette
$7.99·Save 82%·Excellent dupe
Dupe Score 91
Mineral
Fusion Eyeshadow Palette (Coffee Break)
$9.09·Save 80%·Excellent dupe
Dupe Score 91
Mineral
Fusion Eyeshadow Palette (Speakeasy)
$10.98·Save 76%·Excellent dupe
Dupe Score 90
ColourPop
Going Coconuts Pressed Powder Eyeshadow Palette
$6.99·Save 84%·Excellent dupe
Dupe Score 90
L.A
. Girl Pro. 15-Color Eyeshadow Palette, Neutrals GES226
$7.40·Save 84%·Excellent dupe
Dupe Score 89
Maybelline
New York The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette Makeup,…
$6.93·Save 85%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 89
NYX
PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP, Ultimate Shadow Palette,…
$6.99·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 89
Mineral
Fusion Eyeshadow Palette (Girls Night Out)
$9.09·Save 80%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 89
Well
People Power Palette Eyeshadow, Taupe
$12.00·Save 73%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 88
39 Colors
Colorful Rainbow Eyeshadow Palette, Matte Metallic…
$8.99·Save 80%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 88
Almay
Shadow Squad, Never Settle, 1 count, eyeshadow palette…
$8.79·Save 80%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 88
Bh Cosmetics
Solar Flare 18 Color Baked Eyeshadow Palette
$9.95·Save 78%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 86
Maybelline
New York Shadow Blocks Shadow Blocks Eyeshadow…
$7.62·Save 83%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 86
ColourPop
Under the Sea Eyeshadow Palette by ColourPop
$18.00·Save 60%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 85
Physicians Formula
Shimmer Strips Eyeshadow, Multi-Finish Nude Palette…
$8.59·Save 81%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 84
Revolution
Maxi Reloaded Eyeshadow Palette, Includes 45 Shades in…
$7.90·Save 82%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 84
Maybelline
The Nudes Eyeshadow Palette Makeup, 12 Pigmented Matte…
$9.99·Save 78%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 84
Klarity
Kosmetics Chokolate Seduction Neutral Brown Gold Matte…
$9.99·Save 78%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 84
PÜR
MINERALS On Point Eyeshadow Palette, Matte, Shimmer…
$10.98·Save 76%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 83
SHANY
Natural Fusion Eyeshadow Makeup Palette - 88 Color…
$9.99·Save 78%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 83
Bh Cosmetics
Baked Eyeshadow Palette, Aurora Lights
$19.49·Save 57%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 82
Pacifica
Eyeshadow Palette – Animal Magic with Colorful…
$10.98·Save 76%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 81
Sigma
Beauty Cool Neutrals Eyeshadow Palette, 14 Shades,…
$16.10·Save 64%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 80
Kiko
Milano Glamour Multi Finish Eyeshadow Palette
$20.00·Save 56%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 79
LORAC
Unzipped Eyeshadow Palette, Matte And Glitter Finish
$21.25·Save 53%·Solid match
Dupe Score 79
SIGMA BEAUTY Quad Eyeshadow Palette
Tiramisu Eyeshadow Quad, 4 Shades
$21.25·Save 53%·Solid match
Dupe Score 67
LORAC
Mini PRO Eyeshadow Palette Matte Shimmer, Metallic…
$23.00·Save 49%·Worth a look
How we rank dupes
- 1. Category matchSame product type — eyeshadow vs eyeshadow, not random cross-sells.
- 2. DupeScoreSimilarity, savings %, and editorial confidence combined into one 0–100 score.
- 3. Side-by-side proofEach pick links to a full compare page with prices, specs, and an honest verdict.